Showing posts with label White Privilege. Show all posts
Showing posts with label White Privilege. Show all posts

Thursday, March 16, 2017

White Privilege in Children's Literature


Because children’s literature has only come into prominence in the last hundred years or so, it mirrors the world as it was viewed throughout those decades. Diversity and moral integration, though making significant headway in through the twentieth century, had yet to integrate itself into the books we give our children to read. Books touch cords in readers’ lives and therefore develop staying power. These books can’t be removed from society any more than they can be removed from readers’ hearts.

Now that society is becoming more aware of the invasive proliferation of discrimination and prejudice, and its constancy in children’s literature, experts can analyze past books, including the most beloved titles, to determine how they underscore white privilege. In Kay Thompson’s Eloise, for example, Eloise declares that the Plaza Hotel (her home) has “ever a lot of things going on down there… Altogether I have been to 56 affairs including Halloween” (Thompson, 1955). While this may seem like a completely innocuous statement, the accompanying illustration shows several presumably white people (there is not a person of color in the entire book) wearing ethnic garb—turbans, hajibs and saris—as Halloween costumes. This intimates that these ethnicities are nothing more than entertainment or novelties and denies them the respect and dignity they deserve.
Thompson, Kay/ Knight, Hilary (ILT)/ Peters, Bernadette (NRT). (2015). Eloise. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.

Counting Rhyme: Ten Little Indians, illustrated by T. Isawa and S. Hijikata, is a product of the late 1960s and may well have taken its stereotypical illustrations from the popular Western movies and television shows. All ten Native Americans are wearing buckskin, headdresses, moccasins and feathers. Several teepees are depicted, all place in the desert. One town is mentioned, but from the rhyme, it is evident that it is not the Native American’s home (Tadasu & Hijikata, 1968):

Tadasu, I., & Hijikata, S. (1968). Counting rhyme ; ten little Indians. New York: Grosset & Dunlap.
This is a subtle indicator that Native American living arrangements are sub-par and inferior to standard white society living arrangements.

Although these characters are created to be cute and playful, a careful analysis reveals their facial characteristics to be slightly menacing. Their eyes have an upward slant at the outer corners and their eyebrows furrow inward. This could subversively indicate a stereotypical mindset that Native Americans are savage.

While these images may depict the 1960s perspectives of Native Americans, readers and experts alike can now recognize how minimizing these stereotypes are. Certainly, some Native American tribes wore such clothes and lived in teepees outside of American towns, but many more did not, and continuously do not, fit neatly into these typecasts.




Wednesday, March 15, 2017

White Privilege Explained

White privilege is being able to purchase bandages that match one’s own skin tone.

White privilege is walking into a grocery store and finding ingredients for a meal from one’s culture outside of the “ethnic foods” aisle.

White privilege is learning the history of one’s own race as “American history”.

White privilege is never having one’s intelligence or position of authority questioned based on the color of their skin.

White privilege is seeing characters predominantly of one’s own race in books, movies, and TV shows.

White privilege is an inherent entitlement to conveniences based on the color of one’s skin.


“[White privilege] is the level of societal advantage that comes with being seen as the norm in America, automatically conferred irrespective of wealth, gender or other factors. It makes life smoother, but it’s something you would barely notice unless it were suddenly taken away — or unless it had never applied to you in the first place” (Emba, 2016). White privilege is an “unearned power conferred systematically” based on the color of one’s skin (McIntosh, 1989). These powers and advantages are granted to white people by society, often unconsciously, because light skin has been perceived as the “norm” for so long. The video above (retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hD5f8GuNuGQ) exemplifies just how such advantages affect so many parts of life, every single day. “White skin privilege is not something that white people necessarily do, create or enjoy on purpose...white skin privilege is a transparent preference for whiteness that saturates our society” (Holladay, 2000). Because “white” has been perceived as predominant, even though it is not, and white people have reaped these advantages for many years, many white people have come to accept and expect the advantage of white privilege in everyday life, which has caused many to become blind to the inequities found throughout society. However, as Emba mentions, the inequities are apparent to other races who have watched others reap benefits denied to them for decades.

Image retrieved from:
http://www.gradientlair.com/post/102200016923/white-privilege-cartoon
While the term “white privilege” has been around for several decades, it has just recently entered the mainstream. As more people become familiar with the concept, there is more a push to not only acknowledge its existence, but a movement to eliminate it. In 1989, McIntosh said that “obliviousness about white advantage...is kept strongly inculturated in the United States so as to maintain the myth of meritocracy, the myth that democratic choice is equally available to all” (McIntosh, 1989). The acknowledgment that white privilege exists is the first step in dismantling its unequal benefits within society. However, as Holladay states, “White privilege is a hidden and transparent preference that is often difficult to address. Only on closer inspection do we see how it creates a sense of entitlement, generates perks and advantages for white people and elevates our status in the world” (2000). As DiAngelo describes, white people in America are insulated from race-based stress as if they are “surrounded by protective pillows of resources and/or benefits of the doubt” (2011). This insulation can make it difficult to see that not everyone receives the same treatment or privileges. The recognition of white privilege and the benefits it has afforded white people is the only way to start the process of developing equal opportunity for all races and ethnicities. 

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

White Privilege vs. White Fragility

White privilege infers the advantages and conveniences granted to white people by society for simply being part of what has long been considered “the norm”. White fragility is “a state in which even a minimum amount of racial stress becomes intolerable, triggering a range of defensive moves” (DiAngelo, 2011). White fragility is the raw emotion, often a visceral reaction, felt by many white people when issues regarding unequal treatments of different races are discussed and often include defensive actions when racial advantages and disadvantages are discussed. Defenses include separating oneself from others when accused of receiving certain advantages for being white by seeing oneself as an individual instead of part of a universal, or they downplay the significance of race, such claiming as “colorblindness”. 

Diversity doesn't stick without inclusion.
Retrieved from: https://hbr.org/2017/02/diversity-doesnt-stick-without-inclusion
The actions or reactions, usually performed because of white fragility, actually help promote white privilege, either consciously or unconsciously. White people are rarely asked to speak on a subject as a representative for their whole race and often separate themselves as individuals from others who are accused of benefiting from white privilege, or the “bad” white people. “[White people] are taught to value the individual and to see themselves as individuals rather than as part of a racially socialized group. Individualism erases history and hides the ways in which wealth has been distributed and accumulated over generations to benefit whites today” (DiAngelo, 2011). 

Another example is claiming to be “colorblind” to race, which emerged after the Civil Rights era. “In school, colorblindness can send a message to children that everyone shares the same cultural experience...Translating colorblindness into curriculum also can telegraph messages to children that the cultural experience of being white and middle class is the desired standard” (Fergus, 2017). While white privilege and white fragility are two different entities, they often go hand-in-hand, perpetuating and building off of each other.

White Privilege Around the World

Image retrieved from:
https://blog.shrm.org/archive/2011/09
White privilege is not a phenomenon exclusive to the United States. White people in countries around the world also are given the advantages and the “invisible knapsack” of white privilege. In Asia, for example, white people are more likely to be hired as English teachers, despite whether or not they are the most qualified, because parents believe that white people speak better English (Zhang, 2013). White privilege is so prevalent that some companies even hire fake businessmen to represent them because “having foreigners in nice suits gives the company face” (Moxley, 2010). In many Asian countries, race is divided into three categories - black, white, and yellow - with whiteness highly preferred, according to Zhang. “Asia is believed to be a land free of racism because Asian people seem to talk less about race. However, there is no such utopia where every race and gender can be treated fairly” (Zhang, 2013).

In 1948, apartheid made racial segregation legal in South Africa. Even though it was abolished in 1994, white people still have advantages that other races do not. In her article “A Comprehensive Guide to White Privilege in South Africa”, Gillian Schutte provides 40 examples of white privilege in present-day South Africa, a mere fraction of the privileges that actually exist. One of the most striking examples that Schutte highlights  is “white privilege is claiming you are ‘African’ and into ‘Ubuntu’ but doing and saying nothing about the inequalities you see around you, thus maintaining your white privilege while assuming commonality and brotherhood with those exploited by the system of which you are a beneficiary” (Schutte, 2013). This example shows that many claim equality and “colorblindness” in appearance, but still reap the benefits of white privilege without acknowledging or trying to deconstruct the racially-based system of advantages and disadvantages.

Laura Sherbin and Ripa Rashid, in their article Diversity Doesn’t Stick Without Inclusion, prove the point that white privilege extends into South America as well. They interviewed an “indigenous Peruvian” employee in a Chilean-based company (Sherbin and Rashid, 2017). He “is respected, well-paid, and included in the leadership team’s decision-making discussions” (Sherbin and Rashid, 2017). Yet he confessed that he does not feel his future in the company aligns with his potential. “‘I know they value me,’ he said, ‘but I am an indigenous person, and they are white, legacy, and Spanish. They will never make me a partner, because of my color and background’” (Sherbin and Rashid, 2017).

These startling illustrations of white privilege span the globe, proving that the issue is not constrained inside the borders of the United States, but epidemic in both location and effect, reaching deep into every area of life.

Monday, March 13, 2017

Section References


DiAngelo, R. (2011). White fragility. The International Journal of Critical Pedagogy, 3(3). pp. 54-70.

Emba, C. (2016, Jan. 16). What is white privilege? The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2016/01/16/white-privilege-explained/?utm_term=.bce5225fe4ae

Fergus, E. (2017). Confronting colorblindness. Phi Delta Kappan, 98(5). pp. 30 - 35.

Holladay, J.R. (2000). On racism and white privilege. Retrieved from http://www.tolerance.org/article/racism-and-white-privilege

McIntosh, Peggy. White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack. Independent School, 90(49). p. 31.

Moxley, M. (2010). Rent a white guy. The Atlantic. Retrieved from https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2010/07/rent-a-white-guy/308119/

Schutte, G. (2013). A comprehensive guide to white privilege in South Africa. Retrieved from http://thoughtleader.co.za/gillianschutte/2013/10/11/a-comprehensive-guide-to-white-privilege-in-south-africa-3/


South African History Online. (2016). A history of apartheid in South Africa. Retrieved from http://www.sahistory.org.za/article/history-apartheid-south-africa

Yang, G. L. (2014). Speech presented at National Book Festival in Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/comic-riffs/wp/2014/09/01/read-this-gene-luen-yangs-rousing-comics-speech-at-the-national-book-festival-gala/?utm_term=.5ff243b69c04

Zhang, X. (2013). White privilege and racism are alive in Asia. Retrieved from https://leilaninishime.wordpress.com/2013/12/10/white-privilege-and-racism-are-alive-in-asia/